Paternity Rights And Challenging The Obligation To Pay Child Maintenance (Victoria)

Mothers and fathers have a duty to maintain their children even if they have never lived together. This duty continues until the child reaches the age of 18, unless the child is able to support him or herself before that time, or marries, or is adopted.

The Commonwealth Government enforces the obligations of a parent to pay child maintenance in two ways.

First, a mother or father of a child can obtain orders under the Family Law Act requiring the other parent to make provision for child support as part of the overall property settlement.

Secondly, the Commonwealth Government has established the Child Support Scheme and the Child Support Agency. The Child Support Agency is given wide powers under the Child Support (Registration & Collection) Act 1988 (Cth.) and the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth.).

In relation to parties who separate after 1 October 1989, or have children born after 1 October 1989, the Agency makes an assessment of the child support payable and may collect payments if requested to do so. The Agency is given wide powers to obtain information about the income of parties from the Australian Taxation Office.

The way child support is calculated under the Child Support Scheme is as follows:

– The taxable income of the parent who does not have care of the children is assessed.

– An amount is deducted from that income for the living expenses of that parent and any natural or adopted children living with that parent.

– In some cases, part of the income of the parent with whom the children do live is taken into account, and this reduces the other parent’s liability.

– Finally, a percentage of the first parent’s remaining income is paid as support for the child or children involved. These percentages, after making all of the above deductions, are as follows:

* One Child 18% * Two Children 27% * Three Children 32% * Four Children 34% * Five or More Children 36%

The assessment lasts up to 15 months and will change if further information regarding the income of the parents is received.

The parent who is dissatisfied with the child support assessment can apply for changes of assessment but only if there are special circumstances. Those special circumstances relate to a claim that the original assessment is unfair because the children themselves have substantial assets, or the children are receiving substantial assets from a third party, that the parent’s expenses for self support have increased substantially (e.g. because of a serious illness), or because the parent comes under a legal duty to support another person or other children.

A father can challenge the obligation to pay child support on the issue of paternity.

There are two ways of establishing paternity. The first is under the Family Law Act. The second is under the Status of Children Act 1974 (Vic.)

The Family Law Act establishes certain presumptions of parentage. Like all legal presumptions, they may be counteracted by proof to the contrary on the balance of probabilities.

In other words, the Family Law Act presumes that the man is the father of any child arising from the following:

– Marriage – Cohabitation (or the child being born within 20 weeks of the party separating) – Acknowledging paternity by an instrument such as a birth certificate

Under the Status of Children Act, there is a presumption of parentage in favour of the husband in relation to children born to a married woman and any children born up to 10 months after the marriage dissolves.

Alternatively, evidence of paternity can be established by the father allowing his name being entered in the Register of Births and on a birth certificate, or the father and mother jointly signing a statement in the presence of a solicitor stating that he is the father, or a Supreme Court declaration of paternity.

A father can deny paternity of any child. However, the father has a difficult onus of proof to discharge, particularly if the father has allowed his name to be entered in the Register of Births or on the birth certificate.

One method of disputing paternity is by way of a blood or genetic test. Such testing can now provide positive proof of paternity if a sophisticated form of testing is used. This is known as genetic tissue typing and in particular HLA (Human Leucocyte Antigen) testing.

There is provision for the Family Court under the Family Law Act or any Victorian Court under the Status of Children Act to order blood tests. However, the legislation is not mandatory. The mother can refuse to allow the child to be blood tested. However, in that circumstance, the appropriate Court is empowered to draw such inferences about the refusal to take the test as appear just.

The obligation to pay child support is lifted until the paternity issue is concluded. However, if the father loses, he will have to pay back-payments including interest.

If a father does have reasonable grounds for doubting paternity, then legal advice should be sought swiftly. The Child Support Agency has extensive powers of collection. These involve the garnishing of wages and the imposition of penalties on parents who make payments. The Agency is empowered to take enforcement proceedings to recover arrears of child support. The Child Support Agency can even prevent a parent who has a child support debt from leaving Australia in certain circumstances. The Agency issues a “departure prohibition order” which, quite literally, can require a parent to be taken from a plane immediately prior to take-off for overseas.

The issue of paternity has recently gained public prominence with the High Court of Australia decision in Magill v. Magill decided in 2006.

The issue related to whether a former husband, who for years had considered that he was the father of three children and had paid for their support, could recover damages from their mother when DNA testing showed that he was not in fact the father of two of the three children.

The High Court unanimously rejected Mr. Magill’s appeal and decided that he had no ability to recover damages as a result of paternity fraud on the part of the mother of the children of another man. Various reasons were given by the five High Court Justices. Essentially, the High Court Justices decided that there was no legal obligation within a marriage for a wife to tell the truth to her husband. The tort of deceit and the law of false representations did not apply in the context of a marriage in relation to extra-marital sexual relationships or the issue of paternity.

Accordingly, fathers should take action sooner rather than later to dispute paternity if there are reasonable grounds for opposing any obligation to pay child support. It seems that Australian law will not allow a father to recover child support payments made before paternity was proved when the father wrongly believed that he was the father of children and had contributed to their support.

Michael Pickering is a solicitor employed at LAC Family Lawyers Melbourne. He has nearly 20 years experience as a lawyer.


19 Responses

  1. I really like looking through an article that
    will make people think. Also, thank you for allowing for me to comment!

  2. If you plan to use your motorised home full time, look for coverage similar to homeowners, if you do not then you will want to have a
    storage option on your policy. In turn, the wider
    market has caused the costs for homeowners insurance policies to remain
    stable and even decline. Too many homeowners have signed up for insurance
    policies thinking that they are covered for certain kinds of damages or events but when
    they file a claim, that is the only time they realize that
    they are not qualified to receive anything for those events.

  3. Getting business insurance is of utmost importance and a great responsibility while running a business.
    Furthermore by a detailed comparison you will get insurance with cheaper quotes.
    Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) helps first time home buyers purchase a home with less than 20%

  4. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I in finding It really helpful & it helped me out a lot. I am hoping to give one thing again and help others such as you helped me.

  5. By requiring every driver to carery this minimum coverage,the sate of New Mexico is able to assure alll drivers thqt is they are involved in
    an accident that iss not ttheir fault, the at ault driver will have some means of paying for
    some or all of the costs. The differences are really
    the secret to finding the best discounts available. Include these
    expenses if you choose to takme actual expenses instead of mileage.

  6. While you ccan always have a shelter for yourself, your cars can’t have that.

    If you are involved in a car accident, and the
    auto car insurance of the other party is not enough to cover the expenses, the uninsured
    or underinsured motorist coverage is useful. In any case, a clear
    windscreen should help to make driving safer.

  7. Insurers are wary of this risk, and the chance to slap the driver with higher fees forr car insurance is more likely.
    Thhe amount off this compensation is about AED 200,000.
    Such as an amount off inhabitants will supremely reimburse 100 pounds or 200 dollars
    on a pair off shoes; but several inhabitants
    like tto expend as slight as probable.

  8. Classic car insurance is one of the most difficult
    insurance olicies to gett for the reasoin
    that the vewhicles are very hard to value that many car insurance
    companies may offer the wrong type of coverage or wrong amount of coverage.
    It cannot be denied that there are so many products available in
    the market that one gets confused while buying these plans, as
    each and every product has something unique that a person gets enticed with theese features.
    You can easily compare thhe various policies available by consulting varius websites
    on the Internet, somke off which are dedicated to finding cheap car rates.

  9. There are a number of things you have to considser to get a lower premium onn your vehicle’s insurance.

    Teens are young, so they don’t have much driving experience.
    Many consumers seriously assume that repaying every month is stress-free, nevertheless believe me, yearly settlement might save you a lot of money.

  10. Weekly, monthly, then jump into the five andd ten-year goals.
    If youu are learning to drive thinking about how to
    find the best insurance is probably the last thing you want to think about.
    Anpther is to make sure you avoid accidents, sihce
    claims will usually lead to higher premiums frokm the insurance company.

  11. It is possible to receive as many as 20 car insurance quotes within an hour from some of
    the top directories. If aan insurance policy iss procured under the parent’s name, while the driver is a young one then this is called fronting, and insurance carriers under these conditions do have the rights
    to rescind and nullify the insurance policy. That means
    that if you want to change things, you definitely do want to either renew your current policy or
    shop around for a better deal that will give you the benefits you want.

  12. This situation could frequently arise, for example when a regular
    client of ann insurance advisor mves to another EEA member state and wishes to retain the same advisor.
    The best car insurance for your classic hot rod or your racing
    street rod is specialty caar insurance if you care anything about replacing your carr oor car parts.

    Any kind of accidsnt that happens during that time could be massively damaging to the business.

  13. There is no need to do that any more, not when you
    can go to websites that will give you multiple quotes in just minutes.

    Whether you agree with the thinking behind giving one group a break aand charging anoter one more money, the fact of the matter is
    that the insurance companies hhave mountains
    of statistics that back up their decisions.
    Personal Injury Protection offers broader coverage than
    Medical Payments Coverage, as it may also cover lost wages ddue to work missed because of injjuries caused
    by an accident.

  14. Here you will have to payy yourr deductible and pay for your own rental caar (unless you have rental car reimbursement coverage) uup front.
    Based on above factors, occupations that are considered high-risk
    professions and hve high auto insurance premims are doctors,
    architects, attorneys, lawyers, judges, social workers, businessmen,
    business owners, executives, real estate agents, real estate brokers.

    Online research is miles ahead of thee othber options because itt is the fastest and the most comprehensive
    of all available options.

  15. The amount of premium that the insurance company will return equals the annual premium already
    paid times the percentage that results from dividing the number of
    cancelled days by the total numbver of days of paid-up coverage.
    This coverage protects your vehicle and the other vehicle or vehicles iin
    a accident, or property that’s damaged by you. Thus, even though the
    coverages are expensive, having them is valuable.

  16. Only on website will you be able to compar annd contrast
    all of the car insurance types that are offersd for young drivers.

    You can visit the workplaces associated with local limbs associated with insurande coverage agents.
    There are a lot of different sites that you can go to that wilol give you
    quotes from their company along with quotes from a few competitor’s as well.

  17. But despite of the differences in the way in whiich off punishing these offenders, there is one thing
    a convicted suspect would surely receive as a resut of what she or hee has done which
    is spending a prescribed term in prison. Also 75% of people
    say they take their mobile phones on holiday with them.

    Law enforcement officers can verify some of these online through a California driver’s license.

  18. Firstly at slow speeds a car has greater maneuverability going backwards than
    it does going forwards. Read tnis hanfy dandy article to learn
    how you can obtain cheap car insurance for yooung drivers.
    A driver who has speeded in tthe past will
    speed in the future, and this iss the concept alll insurance companies follow.

  19. The current loan rate on a whole life policy that I ownn is 5.
    Thhe competition that exists in thhe market has forced a number of
    insurance providers to cut down on prices of auto insurance policies without compromising on the type of coverage being offered.
    For this reason, every lender will require proof of insurance.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: